Comparing Brands of Magnetic Tiles

WHY WE LOVE CONNETIX TILES

We are always asked about the Connetix Tiles and how they compare to other brands but we chose to stock Connetix Tiles after our daughters quickly fell in love with them and it became the toy they would play with everyday and for the longest amount of time! We were very surprised at this as we had owned other brands of magnetic tiles before but the love for them was not the same.


Firstly let's start with why we love them. They have continued to be a favourite for almost a year and entertain both our girls (1 and 3) as well as older children and adults when they come to visit!  

Connetix tiles with young child

Connetix Tiles are such a wonderful investment for many developmental stages and being such good quality they will last for many, many years. Connetix Tiles are open ended so there is no right or wrong way to play with them, meaning children will be using their imagination to create with them as they take the lead in their own play.


Whilst playing with them, children are developing so many skills such as hand-eye coordination, colours, fine motor skills, problem solving skills and learning concepts such as cause and effect.

connetix tiles stacked high

While they can cost a lot of money you will find value in the amount of play your children and yourself will gain from them. I’ve had many parents message me telling me how much they love sitting down and playing with them too!  Something that children won’t forget is spending hours playing with their parents and is the base of a happy childhood.


CONNETIX TILES vs PLAYMAGS


We have compared our set of Connetix with our friend’s Playmags sets which have both been owned for almost a year.

From first looking at them together the most noticeable difference in them was the clear windows on the Connetix Tiles vs the bracing through the middle of the Playmags. 

connetix Tiles vs playmags

The amount of scratches on the Playmags compared to the Connetix also affected the look of them, making them less clear to see through. The Playmags are flat where as the Connetix Tiles are slightly concave in the middle meaning they have less scratches and you can easily see through them, even after a lot of use.

connetix tiles vs playmags

Picture above small square - Connetix Tiles (left) vs Playmags (right)

 

In regards to supports through the tiles, Playmags have internal supports in each tile whereas the concave cross acts as the support in the Connetix. 

connetix Tiles vs playmags

Picture above big square - Connetix Tiles (left) vs Playmags (right)

You'll notice from the pictures above that the magnet size is the same. We tried a lot of different ways to test the magnet strength and both seem very similar. The main difference we found was that we were able to hang 5 of the Connectix squares whilst only being able to hang 4 of the Playmags.

This is probably due to the Playmags square being 3 grams heavier than the Connectix. This means once you hang 5 tiles the Playmags were 15g heavier than the Connetix and this small weight difference was enough that the magnet could no longer hold the weight.

connetix Tiles vs playmags

Picture above - Connetix Tiles (left) vs Playmags (right)


The Playmags and Connetix are compatible and work well together, the sizes and shapes of them are all the same on the outside with slight differences of the internal cutouts. For example the small square window on Connetix has 4 squares and the small square window on playmags has two arched windows at the top and two square windows at the bottom.

The Playmags are 6mm thick and the Connetix are 7mm thick but this small difference doesn't change their compatibility. See below picture of 6 tiles stacked.

connetix Tiles vs playmags

Picture above -  Playmags (left) vs Connetix Tiles (right)

Both sets are very durable and neither have seen any breakages but we always recommend checking your tiles every now and then to make sure there are no cracks as it could happen.

connetix Tiles vs Playmags

Picture above - Connetix Tiles (top) vs Playmags (bottom)

Connetix Tiles are out in the playroom most days and also get used at every open day. They are constantly built up high and pushed down.

The Connetix Tiles are also  slightly more affordable than Playmags. The 100 piece Connetix Tiles are $159 vs a 100 Piece Playmags at $190.

connetix Tiles vs playmags

Picture above - Connetix Tiles (bottom) vs Playmags (top)

 

HOW DOES KMART COMPARE?

The Kmart Magnetic Tiles are cheaper but the magnets are very weak compared to the Connetix. Many customers of our store have upgraded to the Connetix Tiles after coming along to our Open Days to build with them in person. They used the Kmart tiles to see if their children would be interested in them. Whilst playing they have said that the Kmart Tiles were unable to stack high due to the weaker magnets and that their children couldn’t pick up their constructions without them falling apart which lead to a lot of frustration.

The magnets in the Kmart tiles are also not sealed well, unlike the Connetix, as there are no rivets and gaps between layers. Connetix Tiles magnets are in cased inside the plastic with rivets holding them shut for extra protection.

There is a reason that the Connetix Tiles cost more - it’s because they are the top quality and are a leading brand in Magnetic Tiles.

 

 

HOW DO MAGFORMERS WORK?

Connectix and Playmags are NOT compatible with Magformers. They are a different kind of magnetic Tiles.

We originally stocked the Earth Tiles (wooden magnetic tiles) but our girls never really fell in love with them like Connetix as they work in a different way.

We found Big Sis became easily frustrated when trying to build big creations in more than one level.  Due to the rounded edges they couldn’t be stacked vertically on top of each other. Each upright piece that you add to a creation needed a side support. This makes them more complicated for young children to use. 

We did however love the natural wood of the Earth Tiles as it was less vibrant than the colourful Connetix Tiles. Even though they are made from wood you can’t recycle/compost the Earth Tiles due to the magnets that are inside them.

Magformers have rounded edges in the same way as Earth Tiles and we decided not to stock these for the same reason. 

 

We hope this write up and photos to compare helps you to better understand some of the different brands of magnetic tiles on the market. If you have anymore questions please don't hesitate to Contact Us.


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published